KENFOX IP & Law Office > Notable Articles (Page 2)

From Europe to Vietnam – Three Questions for Determining the Copyright Eligibility of Functional Products as Works of Applied Art

[/vc_column_text][vc_empty_space height="13px"][vc_column_text] Download In traditional legal thinking, functional products - ranging from sandals and handbags to perfume bottles - have generally been viewed as falling within the scope of industrial design protection rather than copyright. However, the judgment rendered on 12 November 2025 by the District Court of Midden -Nederland in Birkenstock v. Scapino (Case No. C/16/577582 / HA ZA 24-336) marks a significant turning point. The Court affirmed that even products commonly perceived as being primarily functional, such as sandals, may qualify for copyright protection where their appearance results from the designer's free and creative choices and reflects the designer's personal...

Continue reading

Asplund v. Mio: The Real-World Test After Cofemel – When Does a Dining Table Become a Copyright-Protected “Work”?

[vc_row triangle_shape="no"][vc_column][vc_column_text] Download While the landmark Cofemel v. G-Star ruling officially rejected the notion that applied art products are only eligible for copyright protection if they achieve a "high level of artistic merit," current litigation practice raises a far more complex question - a new gray area: Where lies the boundary between an "original creation" and a "common variant" in the furniture sector, where utilitarian function inherently restricts a designer's creative freedom? In disputes over the copying of furniture, decorative lighting, cabinetry, and similar designs, traditional legal thinking is often driven by an industrial design approach: the parties, and even the Courts, tend...

Continue reading

Brompton – When a Folding Bicycle Becomes a “Work” – The Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union

Download Can a functional product—created to satisfy everyday practical needs—be regarded as an artistic “work” eligible for copyright protection? In the conventional thinking of many businesses and even legal practitioners, the answer is almost automatically “no”. Bicycles are associated with patents, clothing and footwear belong to the realm of industrial designs, while sandals and handbags are merely consumer goods. However, the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) in Brompton Bicycle v. Chedech/Get2Get (Case C-833/18) introduced a new perspective: a functional shape may be viewed not merely as a technical solution, but also as the creative expression...

Continue reading

Functional Products: Industrial Design Protection or Copyright Protection in Vietnam?

[vc_row triangle_shape="no"][vc_column][vc_column_text]Download Traditionally, functional products such as sandals, handbags, and perfume bottles have generally been regarded as subject matter best protected under industrial design law. However, the Dutch court judgment of 12 November 2025 in Birkenstock v. Scapino introduced a different perspective by recognizing the possibility of copyright protection for sandal designs based on the criterion of “creative choices.” [/vc_column_text][vc_empty_space height="13px"][vc_video link="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bt9v2U1BHpg" title="Can a Copyrighted Logo Defeat a Trademark Application in Vietnam?"][vc_empty_space height="13px"][vc_column_text] The Dutch court emphasized that although sandals must fulfill the functional purpose of being worn, designers still enjoy substantial creative freedom in determining the shape of the straps, the curvature...

Continue reading

USM v. Konektra: Does a Functional Product Require a Higher Degree of Creativity to Merit Copyright Protection?

Download Conventional legal thinking often takes for granted that “technical product systems”—such as modular furniture sets, replacement parts, or industrial machinery—fall primarily within the regulatory scope of Design Law or Patent Law. Right holders rarely have the fortitude to opt for the copyright mechanism, largely due to a deeply ingrained perception: for applied products, in order to prevent "overlap" with design law, the law must establish a higher, more stringent "creativity threshold" compared to purely literary and artistic works. Against this backdrop, KENFOX IP & Law Office will analyze the case of 1. USM v. Konektra - Liệu sản phẩm mang tính...

Continue reading

Cancellation of Bad Faith Trademark Registration in Laos: The PINDUODUO Case

[vc_row triangle_shape="no"][vc_column][vc_column_text] Download Many jurisdictions in Southeast Asia operate on a first‑to‑file basis for trademark protection. In Laos, the party who first files a trademark application generally secures priority regardless of whether it has used the mark. This rule creates a vulnerability when opportunistic registrants obtain local registrations for internationally known brands before the actual owners enter the market. However, a recent landmark decision by the Lao Department of Intellectual Property (DIP) highlights that the first-to-file rule is not an absolute shield for opportunism. Represented by KENFOX (LAO) IP Service CO., LTD, the true owner of the global e-commerce giant - Shanghai Xunmeng...

Continue reading

Cofemel v. G-Star: The new standard of the European Court of Justice – Can a pair of jeans be considered a “work of art”?

Download

Conventional legal thinking often defaults to the premise that “functional products”—such as a pair of jeans, a pair of sandals, a fashion handbag, or a perfume bottle—fall primarily within the scope of Industrial Design protection. Rights holders rarely consider the mechanism of Copyright, due to the misconception that the form of mass-produced products can hardly meet the threshold of a “work” or a “work of applied art” to warrant protection.

KENFOX IP & Law Office will analyze the case of Cofemel v. G-Star to elucidate how the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) established a new standard in viewing applied designs from a Copyright perspective. The case not only poses the question of whether a pair of jeans—traditionally viewed as a common consumer product—can be recognized as a “work,” but also opens up a broader debate regarding the boundary between utility and creativity. From this, businesses can conceptualize the prerequisites that must be satisfied to determine when a “functional product” can still be protected under copyright law, alongside the industrial design protection mechanism.

1. Background of the incident

G-Star Raw (G-Star Raw CV) is a renowned Dutch fashion company, founded in 1989 in Amsterdam. The brand is globally famous for its denim products (jeans) and its raw, rugged design style. Cofemel (Cofemel – Sociedade de Vestuário SA) is a Portuguese fashion company. It owns the fashion brand Tiffosi, which is highly popular in Portugal and Spain, specializing in the manufacture and trade of ready-to-wear apparel.

In 2013, G-Star Raw initiated legal proceedings against Cofemel, alleging that Cofemel had copied its jeans and t-shirt models named “ARC” and “ROWDY”. The Plaintiff, G-Star, argued that the “ARC” and “ROWDY” models were not merely everyday apparel, but rather the culmination of an intentional, original creative process, thereby qualifying them as “works” eligible for protection under copyright law. Conversely, the Defendant, Cofemel, countered that clothing serves a functional purpose, and such apparel designs cannot be classified as “works” entitled to such protection. Additionally, Cofemel argued that to be eligible for copyright protection, a design must transcend into “art” and possess a specific “aesthetic value” or “artistic effect”.

Image source : www.alamy.com/ www.sgcr.pt and www.aippi.org

The Portuguese Court of First Instance ruled in favor of G-Star, recognizing the ARC and ROWDY models as “works,” ordering Cofemel to cease its infringing acts, and directing the disgorgement of profits. Cofemel appealed the judgment to the Tribunal da Relação de Lisboa (Court of Appeal, Lisbon, Portugal), which subsequently affirmed the lower court’s decision.

The case was further appealed to the Supreme Court of Portugal. This apex court acknowledged that G-Star’s designs were the result of a creative design process featuring specific formative elements, and that Cofemel had incorporated several of those elements into its own products. However, the Supreme Court faced a legal dilemma: the Portuguese Copyright Act did not explicitly define the requisite threshold of “originality” for this category of designs, and judicial practice reflected the view that an “aesthetic effect” or “high artistic value” was required to trigger protection.

Consequently, the Supreme Court of Portugal referred a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) for a preliminary ruling in Case C-683/17, seeking clarification on whether Article 2(a) of Directive 2001/29/EC (the InfoSoc Directive) permits a Member State to reserve copyright protection for designs that produce a “specific aesthetic effect,” in addition to the criterion of “originality”.

Trademark Refusal in Vietnam: What Strategy Enabled the “Three-Circle” Mark to Overcome a Likelihood-of-Confusion Objection?

[vc_row triangle_shape="no"][vc_column][vc_column_text]Download When two figurative marks with nearly identical structural compositions are filed for the same category of goods, the prospects of securing registration for the later-filed application are generally slim. In other words, the risk of refusal is exceptionally high. Many businesses assume that obtaining a Letter of Consent from the owner of the cited mark will automatically resolve the issue. In practice, however, the matter is far more complex. A Letter of Consent is an important supporting piece of evidence, but it is not a legally binding instrument that compels acceptance by the trademark authority. Examiners remain fully entitled...

Continue reading

Overcoming the Territoriality Trap: How FUMARI Blocked a Bad-Faith Trademark Filing in Laos Without Local Registration

[vc_row triangle_shape="no"][vc_column][vc_column_text] Download The Department of Intellectual Property of Laos (“Laos DIP”) recently issued a Notice sustaining an opposition against Trademark Application No. 50354 for “FUMARI” in Class 34, filed by Xuanfeng Biotechnology Sole Co., Ltd. In this matter, KENFOX IP & Law Office represented Fumari Inc. to challenge the adverse party's mark, steering the case to a successful outcome. In its Notice, the Laos DIP confirmed that, following consideration of the opposition based on the relevant reasons and evidence submitted, the opposition was sustained. As a result, the opposed application will not proceed to the substantive examination stage. This is a significant outcome...

Continue reading

KENFOX Attends the INTA Annual Meeting 2026 in London: Expanding Perspectives, Strengthening Global Connections, and Enhancing Professional Capacity

From 2 to 6 May 2026, a three-member delegation from KENFOX IP & Law Office attended the INTA Annual Meeting 2026 in London - one of the world’s largest and most influential events in the field of intellectual property (IP), bringing together thousands of lawyers, professionals, corporations, and IP organizations from numerous jurisdictions....

Continue reading